Current Conditions
30 ° Mostly Cloudy

Login | Subscribe
Loading.... Please Wait.

Letters to the Editor for the Week of Dec. 6, 2012

Thank you to emergency personnel who assisted

Editor, The Sun

On Thursday, Nov. 29, I was one of three vehicles involved in an accident on the corner of Rt. 5 and North Creek Road in Lake View. So many people stopped to help and stayed with us while we waited for help to arrive. I do not know their names but I am hoping some will see this thank you and know your kindness and compassion did not go unnoticed. Also, all of the police officers and fire department personnel were most gentle and caring. Thank you all. Perhaps some day there will be a signal at that corner or a reduced speed limit, as far too many people have been injured or lost their lives at that intersection.

Laura Glista

Lake View

Participation should be priority in youth sports

Editor, The Sun

The numerous youth football leagues across Western New York have just completed another season. There were teams more successful than others as apparent by their final won-loss record and possibly a championship trophy. Hurray! But at what level in youth sports does winning take precedent over the development of all of the players on the team?

In one youth football league, teams must put 11 players on offense and another 11 on defense throughout the game thus giving 22 players a chance to compete.

Another league has a rule built into place where only a handful of players are allowed to play on both offense and defense from the opening kickoff until the final whistle. Again, most of the players are given a fair chance to get into the game.

However, there are other youth football leagues across Western New York that permit the coaches to use their reserves for a specified number of plays such as a minimum five play per game rule. Once the five play limit is up, regardless of any success, it is back to the bench for the “second stringers” until next week with the possible exception of the score being lopsided. As one youth coach stated to me; “It’s all about putting the best players on the field and winning”. Sad, but true.

But go back and read the mission statements for every one of these youth football leagues and you will find virtually the same mantra. “The sole purpose of youth football is teach sportsmanship and help develop the skills of each individual regardless of their talent level”.

A recent proposal by several parents in one of the five play per game leagues would have the reserves from one team play against the reserves from the other team during the first quarter of every game.

This would allow every player an ample amount of playing time when the game was far from decided. It would also make these players feel part of the team, win or lose. Coaches, who prioritize winning would then have to devote more attention to all of the players during every practice regardless of their skill level that would in turn match the league’s mission statement.

Unfortunately, proposals such as the one above that makes sense in the reality of youth sports will most likely be met by opposition and voted down. Remember, youth leagues are controlled by a board of directors comprised of coaches and their relatives.

When they perceive less time for their own children, who are most likely already on the first team, a well thought out response that would help to ‘even the playing field’ is often discarded. It is not about all of the kids, it is about their kid.

Little League Baseball adopted a rule several years ago that every player bat at least once and play two innings in the field during each game. This rule is followed all the way through the Little League World Series in Williamsport, PA each summer. Regardless of the skill level, every player will be guaranteed to play in 33 percent of each game.

But in the confines of the five play rule in certain youth football leagues, it equates to about 8 percent of the game. Basically, you are asking these young athletes, many playing the sport for the first time, to attend practice for 12 hours a week so they can play less than three minutes in a game.

Again, the discrepancy in playing time falls right back into the lap of the league’s board of directors and the coaches. While many (not all) coaches at the youth level will preach that they are there to teach the fundamentals and sportsmanship, the bottom line for most of these coaches is winning. No coach at any level is there to lose. But at the youth level, where every coach is a volunteer and a promotion to the next level (high school) is almost non-existent since most are not certified teachers, the attitude towards winning at all cost can be just as prevalent as the pros.

The ultimate goal for every youth football league should be teaching fundamentals and sportsmanship while providing an equal opportunity for all players to participate and improve their skills.

· Mark Benton


You must be signed in to comment.

Click Here to create a Free Account

Click here to Sign in


2012-12-12 | 10:39:20
Your points are well taken. It seems in a lot of youth sports the overall "winning is everything" attitude is all too often not only in football but in hockey as well. You are absolutely correct about parents/coaches/directors having a personal agenda as to who plays and doesn't. Winning should be the desireable outcome but at what cost??
Join's mailing list.
For Email Marketing you can trust